How do you choose a payment gateway for an Indian D2C website?

The factors that matter when choosing a payment gateway for a small Indian D2C site: UPI experience, success rates, settlement, COD tools, fees and support.

Anadoris Digital · · 4 min read

MasterCard credit cards in jeans pocket
Photo: TheDigitalWay / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

For a small D2C brand, the payment gateway is the last step between an interested buyer and revenue. A gateway that fails a payment, loads slowly or confuses the buyer on mobile costs sales that no ad campaign can win back. Yet many founders choose based on a headline fee alone.

Popular choices in India include Razorpay, Cashfree, PayU and others, and most cover the basics. The differences show up in mobile UPI flows, onboarding speed, settlement timing, support and features such as one-click checkout or COD tools. Here is how to compare them sensibly.

Start with the buyer’s experience

Most Indian D2C buyers pay on a phone, and UPI is often their first choice. The best UPI experience on mobile opens the buyer’s UPI app directly, called intent flow, rather than asking them to type a UPI ID or scan a QR code on the same phone. Test this on both Android and iPhone, with the apps your customers use.

Also check how the checkout behaves inside Instagram’s in-app browser, since much D2C traffic arrives that way. Some payment flows that work perfectly in Chrome struggle to switch to a UPI app from an in-app browser. A gateway that handles this well can make a real difference for brands that live on social traffic.

  • Does UPI intent open the right app smoothly on mobile?
  • Does the payment page load quickly and look trustworthy?
  • Are saved cards and wallets supported for returning buyers, within current rules?
  • Is the payment page clear in failure cases, with an easy retry?
  • Does the gateway support EMI or pay-later options if your price point needs them?

Reliability and success rates

Payment success rates vary by method, bank and time of day, and gateways route transactions differently. Ask each provider how they handle bank downtime and whether they route to alternative paths automatically. Once you are live, monitor your own success rate by payment method; a sudden drop usually signals a technical issue worth raising with support.

A gateway with slightly higher fees but noticeably fewer failed payments can earn you more overall. You will only know by testing and watching the data.

Ask too about the gateway’s own downtime record and status page. Every provider has incidents; what matters is how quickly they are detected, how clearly they are communicated and whether you can switch to a backup during an outage. For a brand running a sale or a big ad push, even a short outage can be costly.

Settlement, refunds and disputes

Cash flow matters for a small brand. Check how settlement works: how long after a payment the money reaches your bank, whether faster settlement is available and at what cost, and how settlement reports match up with orders for your accountant.

  • Settlement cycle and options for faster settlement (check current terms).
  • Refund process: speed, partial refunds and refunds to the original method.
  • Chargeback and dispute handling, with clear timelines for your response.
  • Reports that reconcile easily with your platform orders and accounting.
  • Support channels and response quality when something breaks.

Platform integration and extra tools

Check that the gateway has an official, maintained integration for your platform, whether Shopify, WooCommerce or a custom build. On hosted platforms, also check whether using a third-party gateway changes the platform’s own transaction fees.

Some gateways offer extras useful to D2C brands: one-click or accelerated checkout with saved addresses, COD verification, payment links for WhatsApp orders, subscriptions with e-mandates, and tools to send payment links to convert COD orders to prepaid. Decide which of these you actually need before letting them sway the choice.

Think about the payment methods your buyers actually use. If most orders are UPI and COD, card features matter less than UPI reliability and COD-to-prepaid tools. If you sell higher-priced items, EMI and pay-later options may matter more. Your order data, or a short survey of past buyers, will tell you which methods to prioritise.

Fees, settlement terms and features change, and many are negotiable based on volume. Treat published numbers as a starting point and get current terms in writing from each provider.

Do not overlook onboarding. Gateways review your website, business documents and policies before activating live payments, and some categories face extra checks. Start onboarding well before launch, keep your policy pages and contact details complete, and expect questions. A delayed approval can push back a launch date that ads and influencers were planned around.

Gateway comparison checklist

  • UPI intent flow tested on real Android and iPhone devices.
  • Official integration with your platform, actively maintained.
  • Settlement cycle and reconciliation reports reviewed.
  • Refund and dispute process understood.
  • Support contact and escalation path known.
  • Onboarding documents and policy page requirements met.
  • Total cost compared, including platform transaction fees, for your expected payment mix.

Where to start

Shortlist two or three gateways with maintained integrations for your platform. Complete onboarding with at least two, since approval can take time and a backup gateway is useful anyway. Place real small test payments on your phone with UPI, card and net banking, and compare the experience. Then compare written fee terms for your expected mix. If you want help testing, Anadoris Digital can review your payment flow.

Related service: Websites & Commerce · More on this topic: Websites & Commerce articles

Common questions

Can I use two payment gateways on one D2C site?

On many platforms, yes. Some brands keep a second gateway as a backup during outages or to offer a specific method. Check your platform’s rules, since some allow only one primary card gateway, and make sure the checkout stays simple for buyers.

What documents do Indian payment gateways ask for?

Usually business registration proof, PAN, GST details where applicable, bank account details, identity proof of signatories, and a live website with product pages, pricing, contact details and policy pages for returns, refunds, shipping, privacy and terms. Requirements vary by provider and business type.

Is the lowest fee gateway the best choice?

Not necessarily. Payment success, mobile UPI experience, settlement speed, refunds and support often affect revenue more than a small fee difference. Compare the total impact on completed orders and cash flow, not only the published rate.

Your next chapter

Let’s build what comes next.

A new website. A better system. A simpler way to work. Tell us where you want to begin.

Discuss your project